Skip to main content

Poe's Short Stories: Dr. Jay Mehta's task




The mysterious, secretive and dark settings characterize the stories of the writer who is considered to be the inventor of detective fiction, i.e Edgar Allan Poe. Mostly known for his short stories and poetry, Poe's own life was quite mysterious and controversial itself. However, that's not what this post is all about. This post explores how, writers of those times, especially writers of detective fiction like Poe, could create some of the spine-chilling narratives with nothing but words. Language though often considered a distinct field of study from literature, has a symbiotic relationship with the same.
So here is my answer which ....
asked here ...


1) Alliteration is indeed one of those devices which help the writer in creating a kind of dark setting required for this genre. However, I would rather like to point out the very first line of the story માનસંઘ, i.e 'એક તો એ અંધારી રાત હતી'. The idea of that અંધારી રાત (dark night) sets the mood of the story. The very mention of a dark night arouses a sense of eeriness in the mind of the reader. For a reader who loves to read detective fiction or ghost stories and such supernatural narratives, the dark night itself becomes a cue that something strange or mysterious  is about to happen.

2) In માનસંઘ, the use of adjectives such as નીરસ and નિર્જન for the atmosphere create a kind of scary setting for the story. The mention of the narrator stepping into a puddle (ખાબોચિયું ) on a night where there's pin drop silence creates some sensory images for the reader. Other than that, the discussions between the narrator and the three other characters including માનસંઘ, about the mysterious downfall of anyone who works on Narayan's farm also sets the reader for the pre-established design of the writer.

3) At various instances in માનસંઘ, the natural elements such as the wind, the night, the rain, etc are personified in order to create the dark setting in which the strange events take place. Take for instance the narrative where માનસંઘ narrates his encounter with the ghostly creature on the cliff near Naran's farm. He says,"રાત ના અંધારા ઉતર્યા હતા", which literally translates into the 'darkness of the night was stepping down' . Sounds weird but that's what it means if we take that literally. The fundamental idea of the writer though, was to describe the intense darkness surrounding the area at that time of the night. In which Jayant Khatri succeeds.

4) When I started reading માનસંઘ , it was around 12:00 in the night so of course by the time I reached the narration of the scary experiences, I was scared too. This is something which every reader could relate to. When you're lost in a story and then suddenly a scary narrative comes up and then again if you're alone in a room, chances are you'll get scared to death. This happens with scary movies also. Unfortunately I wasn't able to listen to the second story, so don't know how that would've felt.

Secondly, when I finished reading માનસંઘ , there was this sense of grief mixed with uncertainty. Simultaneously, there was also a sense of despair as it ended with 'એ સવાર ઉઘડવાને બહુ બહુ વાર હતી'.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Archetypes of Literature.... Northrop Frye

Northrop Frye, in full Herman Northrop Frye, Canadian educator and critic who wrote much on "Canadian Literature" and culture and became best known as one of the most important literary theorists of the 20th century. 1.What is Archetypal Criticism? What does the Archetypal critic do? In literary Criticism the term " archetype" denotes recurrent narratives designs, patterns of actions, character- type, themes & images which are identifiable in a wide variety of works of literature, as well as in myths, dreams and even social rituals. Such recurrent items are held to be the result of elemental & universal forms or patterns in the human psyche, whose effective embodiment in a literary work evokes a profound response from the attentive reader, because he or she shares the psychic archetypes expressed by the author. 2.What is Frye trying to prove by giving an analogy of "Physics to Nature" & "Criticism to Literature"? Northrop...

assignment paper 8 Media Hegemony

Name :- Vidhya Pandya Semester :- MA -2 Roll No :- 32 Subject: -The Cultural Studies Enrolment No :- 2069108420190031 Year :- 2018-20 E-mail id: - vidhupandya10497@gmail.com Submitted to:- Department of English Paper no:- 8 Topic:- Media hegemony Media hegemony is a perceived process by which certain values and ways of thought promulgated through the mass media become dominant in society. It is seen in particular as reinforcing the capitalist system. Media hegemony has been presented as influencing the way in which reporters in the media – themselves subject to prevailing values and norms – select news stories and put them across. A form of hegemony The concept of hegemony, first put forward by Antonio Gramsci (1971), refers to the moral, philosophical, and political leadership of a social group, which is not gained by force but by an active consent of other social groups obtained by taking control of culture and ideology. During this process, the lea...

Rivers and Tides : Andy Goldsworthy

Have you ever seen wind and water making art by themselves? Have you ever seen an artist who without any particular tool makes beautiful piece of art? Have you ever thought Time can make art more beautiful? Have you ever meet a person who don’t believe in immortality of art? Well here it is. Andy Goldsworthy is a British sculptor, photographer and environmentalist who produces site-specific sculptures and land art situated in natural and urban settings. He don’t use any particular tool to create his piece of art. He goes to the nature, finds something which is given by nature, and after making it give it back to the nature. He is working with time. He knows when the sea will touch his work. He knows after how many days the art will show up. With that understanding of time he creates something beautiful. He believes in flow, flow of everything. He also says that everything has fluidity. Here we are talking about his documentary, “River and Tides – Working with Time” What...